Are We In A Recession?
So What is a Recession?
There seem to be as many definitions as people you ask. The extreme negativity of consumer sentiment leads many to believe that if things feel so bad, it must be a recession. But the final arbiter of recessions is the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER), a nonprofit research organization that has been declaring official recession dates since 1920.
Yes, they deserve criticism for their slow and often obvious declarations of the beginning and end of recessions, but the NBER’s definition is far more robust than the two-negative-quarters rule. The NBER defines a recession as a significant decline in economic activity that is spread across the economy and lasts more than a few months, which meets the committee’s view of depth, diffusion and duration. No mention of consecutive quarters or real GDP.
Considering the nuances of this cycle - thanks to the Covid-induced economic sudden stops, restart and ongoing normalization of the post-pandemic economy - this framework may be far more useful than the old two consecutive quarters rule.
Why Does This Look Like a Recession?
Even if you subscribe to the two-quarters rule, there’s good reason to discount the first quarter GDP print and the current data as well. GDP can be subject to significant fluctuations due to the mechanics of its measurement. Specifically, two components can create a lot of noise and, in the case of today’s continuing economic normalization, a lot of distortions: net exports and change in inventories.
Let’s Start With Net Exports
The simple product of robust US consumer demand and weaker global consumption is a massive trade deficit. With the US a largely insulated economy, exports represent a relatively small portion of GDP – on the order of about 10%.
US consumer demand has been strong and requires sizeable imports to meet it. The net effect is a trade deficit: more imports than exports represent a drag on US GDP. That’s not unique, as the US has consistently run a trade deficit for the last 30 years (Figure 1).
Figure 1 – US Trade Deficit (1/31/92–5/31/22)
The Second Culprit: Change in Inventories
Remember that GDP growth is a flow. A slower rate of inventory growth translates to a drag on overall growth – meaning companies are producing less as they draw down on inventories generated in prior quarters. So, even if inventories are growing, representing increased production and economic activity, if they grow at a slower pace than the prior quarter, it translates into lower GDP growth.
Over time, contributions to growth from inventories tend to net out, but over short windows they can have significant impacts. These impacts have been magnified as the world continues to normalize from the Covid shock. In Q1 2022, inventories grew at the second fastest pace on record, increasing by $188.5 billion. But that was on the heels of the largest inventory growth on record in Q4 2021. The result was a 35bp (0.35%) drag on headline GDP growth.
So what did we see in the second quarter? More of the same. Much-maligned goods shortages have quickly morphed into a supply glut as business inventories have exploded in recent months. Retail inventories (excluding autos, where production is likely to continue to hold up as the well-known semiconductor shortage continues to ease) are now 17% above the pre-pandemic trend.
Too much inventory, paired with continued normalization in consumer spending away from goods and back toward services, means retailers are now rolling out plans for major price discounts to draw down those inventories. As a result, corporates grew inventories at a substantially slower pace of $81.6B in Q2 as compared to breakneck pace in Q1 resulting in a 2% drag on GDP growth (Figure 2). (The good news is price slashing is exactly the help we need on the inflation front.)
Figure 2 – Change in Private Inventories (12/31/99–6/30/22)
Why Isn’t This a Recession?
Despite the gloomy GDP data, a simple look under the hood continues to show a more robust US economy than the headline suggests. Final Sales to Domestic Purchasers strips out those volatile components, while Final Sales to Private Domestic Purchasers further strips out government expenditures to provide a cleaner look at underlying demand momentum. On both a real and nominal basis, these two measures of domestic demand in fact drifted higher from Q3 2021 to Q1 2022. While on a real basis these figures flatlined in Q2 2022, on a nominal basis they continue to suggest a robust nominal GDP growth environment (Figure 3).
Figure 3 – Alternative Output Measures (1/31/21–6/30/22)
And consumption seems unlikely to stall, as the economy has added 2.74 million jobs in 2022. That’s an average monthly rate of 456,000 jobs, and well ahead of the pre-Covid average of 191,000 jobs per month. Of course, all trends are subject to change but employment is one of the key metrics the NBER looks at to define recessions, and current data certainly doesn’t indicate that we are in a recession.
Figure 4 – Total Retail and Food Service Credit Card Spending (2/11/20–7/12/22)
Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis
What to make of the Q2 print?
While Q1 largely reflected the mechanical effects of GDP measurement and the continued rebalancing of the US and global economies in the wake of the pandemic, Q2 GDP did show some early signs of slowing growth. Fixed investment was a notable drag, as growth in non-residential investment, or capex, slowed to a halt as residential fixed investment contracted 14% as rapidly rising mortgage rates bit into the housing market. The result was a 2.7% drag on growth. And fiscal drag continued for the third consecutive quarter, shaving off an additional 33 basis points. Finally, while the bedrock of the economy, consumer spending, moderated from the prior quarter, growing only 1%, it continued to reflect the rebalancing of the economy, as goods consumption declined 4.4% while services consumption grew 4.1%. In short, there are indeed sings of tighter policy and continued normalization translating to slower growth, but it by no means confirms we are in a recession today.
What Would Indicate We’re Headed for a Recession?
The indicators that tell us we’re not in a recession are unsurprisingly the same ones to monitor for signs we’re headed in that direction:
- A materially slower industrial sector.
- Declining consumer demand and signs of retrenching.
- And most importantly, signs of a significant slowing in labor markets: higher claims, declining payroll growth or outright losses, and a rising unemployment rate.
What Does This All Mean for Markets?
All of this discussion of a recession now is really a red herring. Markets are forward discounting, and the real question of recession is whether one is on the horizon in 6-12 months and, perhaps even more importantly, what that recession actually looks like. What’s priced in already is what really matters for markets and, even after the modest bounce off the mid-June lows, the stock market is still fully pricing in a mild recession and has done much of the heavy lifting for a routine average recession.
Outside of stock prices, there’s little compelling evidence that a recession is indeed imminent. Industrial metals are raising some red flags, but much of that is the result of the price spikes in the wake of the Russian invasion of Ukraine, and the subsequent unwinding of speculative inflation hedging flows. High yield bonds, typically the canary in the coal mine for fundamental economic damage, are hardly ringing alarm bells.
So, what might a recession look if one is indeed in our near future? We have little in the way of the pre-conditions for a deep and protracted recession with a significant earnings contraction:
- Starting conditions matter. Household and corporate balance sheets are simply too strong to see a drawn-out debt deleveraging and balance sheet repair cycle that made the Great Financial Crisis so painful.
- The power of the Fed’s forward guidance has led to a popping of nearly every pocket of excess over the past year, as markets repriced to a tighter monetary backdrop. What bubbles are left to deflate?
- Commodity prices have come well off their highs and, while elevated commodity prices pressure lower-income consumers, the pass-through to broad demand destruction simply isn’t what it was in prior commodity shock environments.
- Despite the narrative that the Fed is intent on crushing inflation and growth along with it, they are, instead, guiding it lower and prepared to be nimble and pivot rapidly, if need be.
We’re likely in for some choppy markets until we get more clarity on the key overhangs of inflation and the Fed, and elevated rate volatility continues to ripple across assets and depress risk appetite. But, that skew continues to suggest we’ve already done a lot of the heavy lifting to price in an average recession that seems unlikely to materialize imminently, if at all. And, if it doesn’t materialize and that soft landing probability is higher than currently priced in, be prepared for a vicious bounce.
Once more for good measure: We’re not in a recession today.
All investing involves risk, including the risk of loss. Investment risk exists with equity, fixed income, and alternative investments. There is no assurance that any investment will meet its performance objectives or that losses will be avoided. Investors should fully understand the risks associated with any investment prior to investing.
CFA® and Chartered Financial Analyst® are registered trademarks owned by the CFA Institute.