Could market leadership shift from growth to value?
The chief concern regarding AI stocks these days is capital availability. The AI infrastructure buildout is very capital intensive, and cash flow has not been enough to cover expenditures. This has pushed many AI companies, including the hyperscalers, to issue large amounts of debt. Meanwhile, smaller AI companies have been seeking to go public, and even large-cap AI companies have recently started issuing equity to help cover investment costs.
The growth in demand for capital to fund AI investment, along with the fact that many governments around the world are running massive budget deficits, has put upward pressure on global bond yields. Higher interest rates have placed downward pressure on tech valuations. The problem is that if capital availability dries up too badly, investment plans will need to be cut back, and AI-related profits might fail to meet expectations. These fears have weighed on sentiment toward the tech space and prolonged the correction in AI stocks that began back in June.
When it comes to the real economy, though, things are booming. The first estimate of third-quarter GDP showed the US economy growing 3.4%, up from 2.2% in the prior quarter. Meanwhile, consumption increased by 3.8% for the second quarter in a row despite worries about high oil prices and the rising cost of living in the US. If AI revenues decelerate while consumption growth remains robust, we could see a transition from a growth-led market to a value-led one. Over the past month, financial, health care and consumer stocks have done remarkably well, while tech stocks have weakened.
October model performance
Tactical model performance was mixed in absolute terms on both a gross and net basis during October. The more aggressive models delivered slightly negative returns, while the more conservative models produced slightly positive returns. This was due to stocks being down for the month while bonds rallied. Relative performance was also mixed across model sets and risk levels.
In our moderate-risk models, asset allocation and style selection both detracted from relative performance, while manager selection added value. Asset allocation detracted because of our underweight position in fixed income, which outperformed during October as yields fell. Style selection detracted because of our positions in AI-related ETFs, which sold off sharply toward the end of October amid concerns about the availability of financing for AI capital expenditures.
Some of our AI positions are tactical trades, including BBJP for Japan and EMXC for emerging markets excluding China. Others are part of a portfolio overlay strategy intended to complement our active equity managers, who are underweight technology. The overlay positions include XLK and SOXQ. Manager selection added value thanks to strong returns from Loomis Sayles Growth Fund (LSGRX) and the Oakmark Fund (OANMX). These funds are underweight the AI trade and benefited from October’s weakness in that theme.
Natixis model portfolio positioning
We made no additional trades in our models beyond the early October trade highlighted in last month’s Model Portfolio Pulse. As a quick recap, with that trade we added 1% to our stock overweight, extended duration in fixed income and introduced a hedging strategy to help manage sector underweights resulting from our active equity managers. This overlay strategy led us to buy some technology ETFs at a less-than-ideal time, but we view it as a process enhancement that we look forward to incorporating consistently. Our purchase of long-duration Treasury bonds was much better timed and helped offset the weakness in our technology ETFs.
We’re expecting a year-end rally despite October’s volatility, which is why we are overweight stocks. The strong growth backdrop is another reason. We’re closely watching market leadership and looking for evidence of a meaningful shift toward value stocks and away from growth. For now, we’re positioned with a growth bias, but we can adjust that if market conditions warrant.
At month-end, model positioning was characterized by:
- Overweight stocks versus bonds
- Overweight US stocks versus international stocks, both developed and emerging
- Holding technology and semiconductor ETFs to complement our active managers
- Overweight duration within fixed income through long-term Treasuries