A supply crunch, not a new paradigm
Take the recent momentum in the memory and digital storage semiconductor industry. According to Morningstar figures, the Russell 1000® Growth benchmark’s exposure to the semiconductor industry was more than six standard deviations above its 35-year historical average as of June 30, 2026.
Much of the current excitement centers on the AI-driven data center buildout, which has created a temporary supply crunch in memory and storage chips. For chipmakers, the result has been windfall pricing, margins, and profits well above historical norms. The market has rewarded many of these lower-quality, highly cyclical companies as if this pricing power is permanent, not simply reflecting a favorable moment in the cycle. What we see is a supply–demand imbalance. Imbalances like this tend to contain the seeds of their own correction.
Higher prices invite new capacity as well as innovation. As supply catches up to demand, pricing power fades and margins normalize. And if hyperscalers happen to pause AI capital spending as supply increases, these chip stocks could face an even sharper cyclical downturn.
Near-term market enthusiasm should not be confused with durable business quality. Navigating markets means distinguishing between:
- Price and value
- Volatility and impairment
- Temporary popularity and sustainable business quality
Most memory and storage chips are undifferentiated, drop-in replacements for one another. Because this makes switching costs low for buyers, most chipmakers do not have structural pricing power. We believe stocks of these chipmakers are riding a wave of temporary pricing power that will inevitably crest and break. We don’t believe this chip cycle is different.
Not all margin expansion is created equal
In our view, elevated margins are structural and durable only when they’re supported by ongoing innovation and differentiation that continues to improve the product in comparison to peers and earns a company an increasing share of industry profits. Look at Nvidia. Its Vera Rubin architecture coming to market in the second half of 2026 commands a significantly higher price than its prior-generation Blackwell stack via a roughly tenfold (10x) improvement in compute power and energy efficiency. By delivering increased value to its customers – lowering the total cost of performance while expanding revenue-generation opportunities – Nvidia earns its pricing power, reinforcing its competitive advantage and its ability to generate cash flow growth. That is a company widening its moat, not just riding a cyclical wave.
Nvidia’s advantage did not appear overnight. It reflects decades of focused investment, accumulated know-how, and a software ecosystem that has attracted millions of developers. As AI adoption broadens, we believe this foundation positions Nvidia to continue to benefit from the long-term shift toward accelerated computing.
What this can mean for you
Markets periodically convince themselves that technological disruption means the old rules of price and value no longer apply. Investors are right to recognize the scale of the disruption but wrong to assume it changes the rules. Even as AI reshapes parts of the economy, we believe the nature of successful companies remains the same: durable competitive advantages, pricing power, and sustainable, profitable growth.
None of this is a prediction about when market rationality will return to the chip industry. It’s a statement about process. A portfolio built with valuation sensitivity, downside risk awareness, and patience may lag when markets are paying any price for the current favorite.
Our long-term outperformance has never come from getting every quarter right. We haven’t, and we won’t. It comes from never abandoning our process simply because the market disagreed with us for a while. We believe discipline matters most when it is being tested. Right now, the market disagrees with us. Loudly. Periods of underperformance can be uncomfortable, even when they are an inevitable part of active investing.
We are not asking you to ignore the discomfort of the moment. We are asking you to understand it in the context of a process designed to distinguish temporary enthusiasm from durable value, and to recognize that long-term results come from adhering to that process – not abandoning the principles that shaped the portfolio in the first place.